5/13/09 02:14 pm - The white elephant question.
I saw X-Men origins the other day. I was amazed by the stupidity inherent in the plot, but I think they're taking their lead from the real world.
X-Men:
Stryker says "Find him [Wolverine] and cut his head off."
Nobody asks how. They just go to it. Given this is just after Wolverine got his skeleton infused with indestructible adamantium, "how" strikes me as a good question that needs answering before tackling the job.
US Government:
Obama earmarks 19bn dollars for installing equipment to process electronic health records.
Nobody asks how. Nobody asks what an electronic health record is. To me electronic health records are stuck in the limbo of stupid. They cannot be standardised in the old way until the medical industry has some form common practice to standardise. There is no common practice, because senior management do not want to buy two computer systems (one now, and one when the standards come in) so they are not developing common practice for electronic store of health records. Until they do there can be no standards based on the common practice of the industry.
I guess we'll just have to make do with standards constructed from the top down model. Market Research will decide what doctors need, and programmers will program to that specification. Statute can then be used to force doctors to use the system however much time and however many lives it costs.
X-Men:
Stryker says "Find him [Wolverine] and cut his head off."
Nobody asks how. They just go to it. Given this is just after Wolverine got his skeleton infused with indestructible adamantium, "how" strikes me as a good question that needs answering before tackling the job.
US Government:
Obama earmarks 19bn dollars for installing equipment to process electronic health records.
Nobody asks how. Nobody asks what an electronic health record is. To me electronic health records are stuck in the limbo of stupid. They cannot be standardised in the old way until the medical industry has some form common practice to standardise. There is no common practice, because senior management do not want to buy two computer systems (one now, and one when the standards come in) so they are not developing common practice for electronic store of health records. Until they do there can be no standards based on the common practice of the industry.
I guess we'll just have to make do with standards constructed from the top down model. Market Research will decide what doctors need, and programmers will program to that specification. Statute can then be used to force doctors to use the system however much time and however many lives it costs.

